The scores are out and after doing probably alot of homework compared to others doing the brackets I'm somewhat pleased and somewhat peeved at the same time.
I did manage to hit all 68 teams,which for most wasn't that hard this year. Hit 3 of the 4 last 4 in including the correct matchup of Saint Marys and Middle Tennessee,but I lost some points to no fault of my own.
The Selection Committee didn't use the same set of "Criteria" for all the teams. Some got a certain seed because of RPI,some got a certain seed because of who they beat and some got a certain seed because of WHAT THEY MIGHT DO IN THE TOURNAMENT! After hours of actual study for every team here's why I'm a bit peeved.
The RPI teams.
Marquette was obviously slotted into the final #3 seed. Did they have enough quality wins to get here? Probably,but I factored in their BET Quarterfinal loss to Notre Dame,while obviously the committee didn't care,which considering other teams towards the top lines WERE bracketed based on Conference Tournaments is misleading.They beat Wisconsin so obviously that was factored in and more important. Lost a point
Wisconsin could have been viewed several different ways. I viewed them as a team that had so many quality wins that based on that they could have been a #1 or #2 seed.But because of RPI,who they lost to and their style of play they were demoted. Lost 1 point
Florida? C'mon man! This team is the biggest overhyped pile of hot garbage i've ever seen. An inflated RPI and living off of early season wins against Wisconsin and Marquette. Of their 26 wins they only have 5 wins against TOURNAMENT TEAMS and lost to Ole Miss in the SEC Final. OLE MISS for christs sake! I was told later they would be a #3 regardless of the SEC Final result. Good god. Lost 2 points
Then there's the teams towards the top where rather than follow everyone else I studied them and all their computer numbers,great wins,RPI,SOS and seeded accordingly.
New Mexico,Duke,Gonzaga,Georgetown,Kansas State,Saint Louis. How does the #1 RPI and #1 SOS with one of the Top 4 schedules/resumes not get a #1 in Duke? Really stunned they did that. Same with New Mexico sporting a #2 RPI and #4 SOS with enough quality wins to warrant a #2 seed and especially so if Gonzaga is a #1 with a less quality resume. Georgetown simply didn't impress me and they lost in the BET Semifinals. K-State somewhat similar loses in the B12 FINAL who beat Florida,but that's not good enough LOL. Saint Louis played in the A10 so I really didn't see them getting a #4 seed considering there's 16 teams better than them. Unreal. Lost 8 points
Then I made my biggest gaffe with the following teams. VCU,Memphis,Creighton and Wichita State.
VCU profile-Florida Gulf Coast,Belmont,Memphis and Butler
Memphis profile-Nothing
Creighton profile-Wisconsin,Akron,Wichita x2. Guess that Akron win looks better now eh LOL. How about the inexcusable losses? Indiana State,Northern Iowa,Drake and Illinois State. Hmm.
Wichita profile-VCU,Creighton? Bad losses- Evansville twice {Once on Senior Night} Indiana State and Northern Iowa.
I ended up scoring 0 points with these 4 teams because I thought so little of them. Easily lost 5-7 points with this group.
I still wouldn't have been at the top,but I would have been within 5-7 points of the top if the same "Criteria" was used for most all the teams and it clearly wasn't. Nobody got Oregon right LOL. I will say I was happy with the middle of the bracket making up some of the gaffes with the Illinois,Minnesota and Temple picks that not alot of others got right. Overall I'll give myself a Year 1 grade of an A for the C-/D+ bracket grade I'll probably get,which for the most part was out of my hands.
Next year I'll give more credence to the Conference affiliation of the Committee Chairman as that Conference's teams obviously get favorable seeding.Also certain teams that consistently get overvalued year after year like a Florida and then there's the RPI. It played a huge part where I seeded teams,but I also looked at the entire body of work and while the committee can say that the RPI is only a tool they clearly seeded some teams solely based off of a high RPI. Year 2 should be easier after studying this years bracket. Overall good job to all in the Matrix! Thanks again for having me.
Bracket Masters
Monday, March 18, 2013
Sunday, March 17, 2013
JUICE'S BRACKETOLOGY FINAL BRACKET updated at 3:31 PM CST
EAST
1 DUKE
16 NORTH CAROLINA A&T/SOUTHERN
8 Colorado State
9 Temple
4 Syracuse
13 BUCKNELL
5 Arizona
12 Wichita State/Lasalle
6 Butler
11 Boise State
3 Kansas State
14 IONA
7 OREGON
10 Cincinnati
2 Ohio State
15 FLORIDA GULF COAST
WEST
1 Indiana
16 JAMES MADISON
8 San Diego State
9 CREIGHTON
4 Florida
13 VALPO
5 Ucla
12 BELMONT
6 North Carolina
11 Mississippi
3 WISCONSIN
14 NEW MEXICO STATE
7 Pittsburgh
10 California
2 GONZAGA
15 MONTANA
MIDWEST
1 LOUISVILLE
16 LIU BROOKLYN/LIBERTY
8 North Carolina State
9 Missouri
4 Michigan
13 SOUTH DAKOTA STATE
5 Unlv
12 DAVIDSON
6 Oklahoma State
11 Minnesota
3 Georgetown
14 HARVARD
7 Illinois
10 Iowa State
2 MIAMI,FLA
15 ALBANY
SOUTH
1 KANSAS
16 WESTERN KENTUCKY
8 MEMPHIS
9 Colorado
4 Marquette
13 AKRON
5 SAINT LOUIS
12 Saint Mary's/Middle Tennessee
6 Notre Dame
11 Oklahoma
3 Michigan State
14 NORTHWESTERN STATE
7 Vcu
10 Villanova
2 NEW MEXICO
15 PACIFIC
Saturday, March 16, 2013
JUICE'S BRACKETOLOGY updated at 7:11 AM CST
EAST
1 DUKE
16 NORTH CAROLINA A&T/SOUTHERN
8 Colorado State
9 Temple
4 Syracuse
13 BUCKNELL
5 Arizona
12 Wichita State/Ole Miss
6 Oklahoma State
11 Lasalle
3 FLORIDA
14 IONA
7 OREGON
10 Cincinnati
2 Ohio State
15 FLORIDA GULF COAST
WEST
1 Indiana
16 JAMES MADISON
8 San Diego State
9 Missouri
4 Kansas State
13 VALPO
5 Ucla
12 BELMONT
6 North Carolina
11 Boise State
3 WISCONSIN
14 NEW MEXICO STATE
7 Pittsburgh
10 California
2 GONZAGA
15 MONTANA
MIDWEST
1 LOUISVILLE
16 LIU BROOKLYN/LIBERTY
8 North Carolina State
9 CREIGHTON
4 Michigan
13 SOUTH DAKOTA STATE
5 Unlv
12 DAVIDSON
6 Butler
11 Minnesota
3 Georgetown
14 HARVARD
7 Illinois
10 Iowa State
2 MIAMI,FLA
15 ALBANY
SOUTH
1 KANSAS
16 WESTERN KENTUCKY
8 MEMPHIS
9 Colorado
4 Marquette
13 AKRON
5 SAINT LOUIS
12 Saint Mary's/Middle Tennessee
6 Notre Dame
11 Oklahoma
3 Michigan State
14 NORTHWESTERN STATE
7 Vcu
10 Villanova
2 NEW MEXICO
15 PACIFIC
Friday, March 15, 2013
JUICE'S BRACKETOLOGY updated at 1:17 AM CST
EAST
1 DUKE
16 NORTH CAROLINA A&T/SOUTHERN
8 Missouri
9 Colorado State
4 Wisconsin
13 BUCKNELL
5 Arizona
12 Wichita State-Ole Miss/Alabama
6 Oklahoma State
11 Lasalle
3 Syracuse
14 IONA
7 Temple
10 California
2 Michigan State
15 FLORIDA GULF COAST
WEST
1 KANSAS
16 JAMES MADISON
8 San Diego State
9 CREIGHTON
4 Michigan
13 VALPO
5 UCLA
12 BELMONT
6 Illinois
11 Villanova
3 Kansas State
14 NEW MEXICO STATE
7 Pittsburgh
10 Boise State
2 GONZAGA
15 MONTANA
MIDWEST
1 INDIANA
16 LIU BROOKLYN/LIBERTY
8 North Carolina State
9 Oregon
4 Marquette
13 SOUTH DAKOTA STATE
5 Butler
12 DAVIDSON
6 UNLV
11 Minnesota
3 Georgetown
14 HARVARD
7 VCU
10 Cincinnati
2 MIAMI,FLA
15 VERMONT
SOUTH
1 LOUISVILLE
16 WESTERN KENTUCKY
8 Colorado
9 MEMPHIS
4 FLORIDA
13 OHIO
5 SAINT LOUIS
12 Maryland/Middle Tennessee
6 Notre Dame
11 Oklahoma
3 Ohio State
14 STEPHEN F AUSTIN
7 North Carolina
10 Iowa State
2 NEW MEXICO
15 UC-IRVINE
S-Curve
#1 Indiana
#2 Duke
#3 Louisville
#4 Kansas
#5 Miami,Fla
#6 New Mexico
#7 Michigan State
#8 Gonzaga
#9 Georgetown
#10 Ohio State
#11 Syracuse
#12 Kansas State
#13 Wisconsin
#14 Florida
#15 Marquette
#16 Michigan
#17 UCLA
#18 Butler
#19 Saint Louis
#20 Arizona
#21 UNLV
#22 Notre Dame
#23Oklahoma State
#24 Illinois
#25 Pittsburgh
#26 Temple
#27 North Carolina
#28 VCU
#29 North Carolina State
#30 Colorado
#31 San Diego State
#32 Missouri
#33 Creighton
#34 Memphis
#35 Oregon
#36 Colorado State
#37 Cincinnati
#38 California
#39 Iowa State
#40 Boise State
#41 Villanova
#42 Lasalle
#43 Oklahoma
#44 Minnesota
#45 Wichita State
#46 Maryland
#47 Middle Tennessee
#48 Ole Miss/Alabama
#49 Belmont
#50 Davidson
#51 South Dakota State
#52 Ohio
#53 Bucknell
#54 Valpo
#55 Stephen F Austin
#56 Harvard
#57 Iona
#58 New Mexico State
#59 UC-Irvine
#60 Florida Gulf Coast
#61 Montana
#62 Vermont
#63 Western kentucky
#64 James Madison
#65 LIU Brooklyn
#66 North Carolina A&T
#67 Southern U
#68 Liberty
#
#1 Indiana
#2 Duke
#3 Louisville
#4 Kansas
#5 Miami,Fla
#6 New Mexico
#7 Michigan State
#8 Gonzaga
#9 Georgetown
#10 Ohio State
#11 Syracuse
#12 Kansas State
#13 Wisconsin
#14 Florida
#15 Marquette
#16 Michigan
#17 UCLA
#18 Butler
#19 Saint Louis
#20 Arizona
#21 UNLV
#22 Notre Dame
#23Oklahoma State
#24 Illinois
#25 Pittsburgh
#26 Temple
#27 North Carolina
#28 VCU
#29 North Carolina State
#30 Colorado
#31 San Diego State
#32 Missouri
#33 Creighton
#34 Memphis
#35 Oregon
#36 Colorado State
#37 Cincinnati
#38 California
#39 Iowa State
#40 Boise State
#41 Villanova
#42 Lasalle
#43 Oklahoma
#44 Minnesota
#45 Wichita State
#46 Maryland
#47 Middle Tennessee
#48 Ole Miss/Alabama
#49 Belmont
#50 Davidson
#51 South Dakota State
#52 Ohio
#53 Bucknell
#54 Valpo
#55 Stephen F Austin
#56 Harvard
#57 Iona
#58 New Mexico State
#59 UC-Irvine
#60 Florida Gulf Coast
#61 Montana
#62 Vermont
#63 Western kentucky
#64 James Madison
#65 LIU Brooklyn
#66 North Carolina A&T
#67 Southern U
#68 Liberty
#
No more sugar coating it. No more OMG we're playing well lets rank em high. I know exactly what the Committee does and is all about. Your record? Conference Record? Records to some degree,but the world knows what's going on.
RPI,SOS and who you played and who you beat. Some people are going to be very upset on Selection Sunday. Gonzaga fans included! I will produce an S-curve and go from there. No more checking out what everyone else is saying and doing,but just strictly my thoughts from here on out.
RPI,SOS and who you played and who you beat. Some people are going to be very upset on Selection Sunday. Gonzaga fans included! I will produce an S-curve and go from there. No more checking out what everyone else is saying and doing,but just strictly my thoughts from here on out.
Bracket will be redone from scratch after tonites contests. Alot of things happening. Tennessee,Virginia,Kentucky,Lasalle among others with devastating losses. Maryland beats Duke for a 2nd time and will be back in the running. Iowa hammering MSU at halftime as Maryland/Iowa appear to be the major winners tonite.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)